28 . Mental, not physical pain; what the French theologians call " la peine du dam", the privation of the sight of God.
30. Virgil, "Aeneid", VI.: "Forthwith are heard voices, loud wailings, and weeping ghosts of infants, in the first opening of the gate; whom, bereaved of sweet life out of the course of nature, and snatched from the breast, a black day cut off, and buried in an untimely grave."
53. The descent of Christ into Limbo. Neither here nor elsewhere in the Inferno does Dante mention the name of Christ.
72. The reader will not fail to observe how Dante makes the word "honor", in its various forms, ring and reverberate through these lines, -- " orrevol, onori, orranza, onrata, onorata"!
86. Dante puts the sword into the hand of Homer as a symbol of his warlike epic, which is a Song of the Sword.
93. Upon this line Boccaccio, "Comento", says: "A proper thing it is to honor every man, but especially those who are of one and the same profession, as these were with Virgil. "
100. Another assertion of Dante's consciousness of his own power as a poet.
106. This is the Noble Castle of human wit and learning, encircled with its seven scholastic walls, the " Trivium", Logic, Grammar, Rhetoric, and the "Quadrivium ", Arithmetic, Astronomy, Geometry, Music. The fair rivulet is Eloquence, which Dante does not seem to consider a very profound matter, as he and Virgil pass over it
162 as if it were dry ground.
118 . Of this word "enamel" Mr. Ruskin, "Modern Painters", III. 227, remarks:
"The first instance I know of its right use, though very probably it had been so employed before, is in Dante. The righteous spirits of the pre-Christian ages are seen by him, though in the Inferno, yet in a place open, luminous and high, walking upon the `green enamel.' "I am very sure that Dante did not use this phrase as we use it. He knew well what enamel was; and his readers, in order to understand him thoroughly, must remember what it is,--a vitreous paste, dissolved in water, mixed with metallic oxides, to give it the opacity and the color required, spread in a moist state on metal, and afterwards hardened by fire, so as never to change. And Dante means, in using this metaphor of the grass of the Inferno, to mark that it is laid as a tempering and cooling substance over the dark, metallic, gloomy ground; but yet so hardened by the fire, that it is not any more fresh or living grass, but a smooth, silent, lifeless bed of eternal green. And we know how " hard" Dante's idea of it was; because afterwards, in what is perhaps the most awful passage of the whole Inferno, when the three furies rise at the top of the burning tower, and, catching sight of Dante, and not being able to get at him, shriek wildly for the Gorgon to come up, too, that they may turn him into stone, the word " stone" is not hard enough for them. Stone might crumble away after it was made, or something with life might grow upon it; no, it shall not be stone; they will make enamel of him; nothing can grow out of that; it is dead forever."
And yet just before, line 111, Dante speaks of this meadow as a "meadow of fresh verdure." Compare Brunetto's "Tesoretto", XIII.
"Ora va mastro Brunetto
Per lo cammino stretto,
Cercando di vedere,
E toccare, e sapere
Cio, che gli e destinato.
E non fui guari andato,
Ch' i' fui nella diserta,
Dov' i' non trovai certa
Ne strada, ne sentiero.
Deh che paese fero
Trovai in quelle parti!
Che s' io sapessi d'arti
Quivi mi bisognava,
163
Che quanto piu mirava,
Piu mi parea selvaggio.
Quivi non ha viaggio,
Quivi non ha persone,
Quivi non ha magione,
Non bestia, non uccello,
Non fiume, non ruscello,
Non formica, ne mosca,
Ne cosa, ch' i' conosca.
E io pensando forte,
Dottai ben della morte.
E non e maraviglia;
Che ben trecento miglia
Girava d'ogni lato
Quel paese snagiato.
Ma si m' assicurai
Quando mi ricordai
De sicuro segnale,
Che contra tutto malev
Mi da securamento:
E io presi ardimento,
Quasi per avventura
Per una valle scura,
Tanto, ch' al terzo giorno
I' mi trovai d'intorno
Un grande pian giocondo,
Lo piu gaio del mondo,
E lo piu dilettoso.
Ma ricontar non oso
Cio, ch'io trovai, e vidi,
Se Dio mi guardi, e guidi.
Io non sarei creduto
Di cio, ch' i' ho veduto;
Ch'i' vidi Imperadori,
E Re, e gran signori,
E mastri di scienze,
Che dittavan sentenze;
E vidi tante cose,
Che gia 'n rime, ne 'n prose
Non le poria ritrare.
128. In the "Convito", IV. 28, Dante makes Marcia, Cato's wife, a symbol of the noble soul: " Per la quale Marzias' intende la nobile anima. "
129. The Saladin of the Crusades. See Gibbon, Chap. LIX. Dante also makes mention of him, as worthy of affectionate remembrance,
164 in the " Convito", IV. 2. Mr. Cary quotes the following passage from Knolle's " History of the Turks", page 57:--
"About this time (1193) died the great Sultan Saladin, the greatest terror of the Christians, who, mindful of man's fragility and the vanity of worldly honors, commanded at the time of his death no solemnity to be used at his burial, but only his shirt, in manner of an ensign, made fast unto the point of a lance, to be carried before his dead body as an ensign, a plain priest going before, and crying aloud unto the people in this sort, `Saladin' Conqueror of the East, of all the greatness and riches he had in his life, carrieth not with him anything more than his shirt. ' A sight worthy so great a king, as wanted nothing to his eternal commendation more than the true knowledge of his salvation in Christ Jesus. He reigned about sixteen years with great honor. " The following story of Saladin is from the "Cento Novelle Antiche. " Roscoe's "Italian Novelists", I. 18:--
"On another occasion the great Saladin, in the career of victory, proclaimed a truce between the Christian armies and his own. During this interval he visited the camp and the cities belonging to his enemies, with the design, should he approve of the customs and manners of the people, of embracing the Christian faith. He observed their tables spread with the finest damask coverings ready prepared for the feast, and he praised their magnificence. On entering the tents of the king of France during a festival, he was much pleased with the order and ceremony with which everything was conducted, and the courteous manner in which he feasted his nobles; but when he approached the residence of the poorer class, and perceived them devouring their miserable pittance upon the ground, he blamed the want of gratitude which permitted so many faithful followers of their chief to fare so much worse than the rest of their Christian brethren. "Afterwards, several of the Christian leaders returned with the Sultan to observe the manners of the Saracens. They appeared much shocked on seeing all ranks of people take their meals sitting upon the ground. The Sultan led them into a grand pavilion where he feasted his court, surrounded with the most beautiful tapestries, and rich foot-cloths, on which were wrought large embroidered figures of the cross. The Christian chiefs trampled them under their feet with the utmost indifference, and even rubbed their boots, and spat upon them. "On perceiving this, the Sultan turned towards them in the greatest anger, exclaiming: `And do you who pretend to preach the cross treat it thus ignominiously? Gentlemen, I am shocked at your conduct. Am I to suppose from this that the worship of your Deity consists only in words, not in actions? Neither your manners nor
165 your conduct please me.' And on this he dismissed them, breaking off the truce and commencing hostilities more warmly than before."
143. Avicenna, an Arabian physician of Ispahan in the eleventh century. Born 980, died 1036.
144. Avverrhoes, an Arabian scholar of the twelfth century, who translated the works of Aristotle, and wrote a commentary upon them. He was born in Cordova in 1149, and died in Morocco, about 1200. He was the head of the Western School of philosophy, as Avicenna was of the Eastern.
Canto 5
1. In the Second Circle are found the souls of carnal sinners, whose punishment
"To be imprisoned in the viewless winds,
And blown with restless violence round about
The pendent world."
2. The circles grow smaller and smaller as they descend.
4. Minos, the king of Crete, so renowned for justice as to be called the Favorite of the Gods, and after death made Supreme Judge in the Infernal Regions. Dante furnishes him with a tail, thus converting him, after the mediaeval fashion, into a Christian demon.
21. Thou, too, as well as Charon, to whom[*]Virgil has already made the same reply, Canto 06. 022.
28. In Canto 01. 060, the sun is silent; here the light is dumb. 51. Gower, "Confession Amantis", VIII., gives a similar list "of gentil folke that whilom were lovers," seen by him as he lay in a swound and listened to the music Of bombarde and of clarionne With cornemuse and shalmele."
61. Queen Dido.
65. Achilles, being in love with Polyxena, a daughter of Priam, went unarmed to the temple of Apollo, where he was put to death by Paris. Gower, "Confessio Amantis ", IV., says:--
"For I have herde tell also
Achilles left his armes so,
Both of himself and of his men,
166
At Troie for Polixenen
Upon her love when he felle,
That for no chaunce that befelle
Among the Grekes or up or down
He wolde nought ayen the town
Ben armed for the love of her."
"I know not how," says Bacon in his Essay on Love, "but martial men are given to love; I think it is but as they are given to wine; for perils commonly ask to be paid in pleasure."
67. Paris of Troy, of whom Spenser says, "Faerie Queene", III.ix. 34:--
"Most famous Worthy of the world, by whome
That warre waas kindled which did Troy inflame
And stately towres of Ilion whilome
Brought unto balefull ruine, was by name
Sir Paris, far renown'd through noble fame."
Tristan is the Sir Tristram of the Romances of Chivalry. See his adventures in the " Mort d'Arthure." Also Thomas of Ercildoune's "Sir Tristram, a Metrical Romance. " His amours with Yseult of Ysonde bring him to this circle of the Inferno.